Jillian DempseyKhôl Eyeliner | Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil with Built-in Smudger | Long-Lasting Intense Color I Jet Black

This product is wonderful. I have been searching for something I could use on the waterline, would go on smoothly, and stay in place. This product does all 3. By the end of the day, some of the product had moved a bit, but not nearly as much as every other product I had tried and most of it stayed in place. My only wish is that it came in a gray or gunmetal color. Black is a little too dark for me and brown doesn't look good with my coloring. But I will keep using this in black because it is a great product.

I read the reviews and thought this would be perfect: an eyeliner that I could use below the upper lash line that wouldn't disappear. Not only does it not go on there (unless you rub and rub and rub), but it barely adheres to the eyelid above the lash, even when the lid is dry and powdered. When it does adhere, the staying time is short....so, I'll be going back to good old drugstore brands.

I bought this for my waterline. Doesn't work. It does make a lovely smoky eye which I've never been able to achieve before without looking messy. That's mostly due to the smudge tip. That works beautifully. The eyeliner does run on the bottom lid, however. Not quite as bad as cheaper brands, but I still was disappointed by that. You will have to sharpen it, which, for some reason, is always difficult for me. It does not irritate my eyes, even during allergy season. At the price point, I think there are better eyeliner out there. But, the smudge tip almost makes it worth the price.

Doesn't sting, burn, or dry out my eyes! I have really sensitive eyes (I have to wear hypoallergenic mascara or my eyes turn really red) and this goes on my waterline, stays in place, and doesn't irritate my eyes at all.

I bought this eyeliner because it was advertised to hold up in humidity and heat. It’s not a bad eyeliner, but it doesn’t last in heat and humid conditions of the Gulf of Mexico where I live. The color is pretty and it sharpens nicely. Okay but not the best value for the price.