CatkinTinted Lip Balm Color Changing Lipstick Ultra Hydrating 100% Natural Lip Moistrurizer with Vitamin E Nourishing For Cracked & Dry Lips 0.12 oz Pink

This is a very nice lip balm. It prevents chapping and keeps lips soft and moist. The tint (Aurora) was a bit darker than I expected, but still looks natural. Next time I'll try a lighter shade. Some people have commented that the lip balm melts or breaks easily. So far, I haven't had that problem at all. I agree with the others, though, that the case is quite beautiful. But, just like everything else, it's not the packaging that is important -- it's what's inside that counts. And this lip balm inside this case is well worth the money spent.

I gave one away, but I really like the one I kept. (rainbow). The lipstick itself is clear with glitter but turns a nice soft pink shade on the lips. The lipstick itself is a little on the small side ,and has a slight unusual scent, but it's nice. The real star here is the lipstick case. Beautiful Chinese style art work adorns the case. It also has gold accents and a magnetic closure. It's really lovely. The case alone makes it worth the price. Will buy again.

Color was a little light and it doesn't last long. Has a nice slippery feel though... not greasy or thick. Wish it didn't wear off so fast. Picture before and after application.

This is already my second lipstick from this brand, and I absolutely love it. It moisturizes the lips really well and protects them from dryness. The color looks very natural. I especially love the subtle shine the little sparkles give. The lipstick applies evenly and feels completely weightless on the lips. I have two shades — soft pink C10 and C13 — and both look beautifully natural.

I purchased the shade "Amythyst".I've seen this clear color changing lip balms for a while, namely the "winx" brand at target and ulta. I think I tried one on at ulta and did fancy it.I wanted to buy one for a friend of mine as a Christmas present because she's been wanting one. I did some browsing and ended up going with this brand (catkin). It had the highest rating per review, and the packaging was very pleasing, we both love Asian dramas, so this Chinese brand seemed fitting.I was skeptical about if it would work, the colors looked light on the picture. Naturally, I was going to try it out first and then repurchase for my friend if it met my expectations. And oh my god it so did.First of all, my skin is of a medium complexion with olive undertones, and this showed up beautifully! The color I chose is a light pinkier color on the picture, but on my lips it's a little darker, literally just by a shade, and maybe more red. I made my sister try it out, her skin is darker than mine, by a shade or 2, she has more of a brown complexion with neutral undertones, and on her, it deposited pink, very much like the picture. I don't know the mechanism behind ph changing technology in makeup, but these are my results. Both of us loved it.Second, I don't wear makeup often, and I've gotten out of the habit of wearing any lip color. I used to wear a lot of dark colors, liquid lipsticks, and regular lipsticks, but it's such a hassle to maintain it throughout the day. So, this is such a suitable, happy medium for me. I get to wear some color on my lips without looking overkill. If it smears, the color doesn't slide all over the place. It's just so pretty and natural-looking, which I'm now obsessed with.Now, in terms of the color payoff and how long it lasts, it's almost like a stain, I notice that even if the shine of the balm goes away, there's still a light color left over. I don't find it to be dramatically buildable, you can definitely reapply, but it looks like the same shade just refreshed.Third, I'm very sensitive to the feeling of stuff on my skin. I don't like lotion, or the feel of oil on my skin, I hate gloss and most chapsticks because they tend to slide all over the place.BUT THIS BAAABBBYYYY, oooo boi !I am so thrilled to have discovered this brand and product, I actually went on their website to buy an entire set of these. If you have severe dry lips, I don't that this really cater or advertises to those problems, but as far as an every day hydrating lip balm this goes above and beyond. It delivers a very light but nourishing feel with it being to slimy or sticky or dry. Its the goldilocks of balms in my opinion. When I have this on, I don't feel tempted to take it off like I do with others because it's just that comfortable. You don't feel it on your lips but it's there.If you've been looking to buy a clear color changing lip product, I highly suggest going with this brand. It's beautiful both in deposit and packaging; it has a magnetic closure which just feels very luxe, secure and durable. The artwork is just gorgeous, it's effective at delivering a nourishing and comfortable layer on the lips along with sporting a beautiful natural color :)

I love-hate these lipsticks, and I’m conflicted whether to give them another chance and buy again. PROS: the formula feels very creamy and lush on the lips, made my lips look hydrated and soft. The colors are truly beautiful and unique. The packaging is exquisite.CONS: just one big one - the stick melts like butter! Don’t even think about carrying them in your purse to re-apply during the day, the thing might and will break in half or get all mushy in the case. I think the formula would work better in a “cream” packaging, to be applied with fingertips or brushes. Not sure I’d buy again.

Received this lipstick today and it is such a pretty color and is very hydrating. The packaging is so nice and very pretty! I want to buy more of this product in other colors.

OK, this is a decent lipstick. I notice it's not too glossy, the tint is faint, but it's buildable. The case is stunning! But given the price, I don't think the lipstick is all that great.3 for the lipstick, and extra star for the case!