AMY'S DIARY2pcs Matte Red Lip Liner and Lipstick Makeup Set, Liquid Lipstick 24H and Lip Liner Set Matt Liquid Lips Make Up Waterproof Long Lasting Lipstick Matte Kit with Lip liners kit (07)

Overall, this product is pretty good. The lip stain itself is both waterproof and smudge proof and stays on for a long time. The applicator could be better, but it just makes putting the stain on a bit more tedious. The liner on the other hand is not good at all. It doesn't have the same pigment as the stain, it's very hard to apply, and it's not nearly as water and smudge proof as the stain. Besides that, it's good. The only other thing I'd mention is that the dark purple (# 20 and the one I have on in the pic) is very close to black when on the lips. (This is probably different depending on your skin tone, I just have pale skin)

Yes, I gave it only 3 🌟 because of the extremely dry lips after using this product. You must apply lip balm pretty much often during the day, but if you do it the color will fade faster. Other than this, it's, as it was advertised, very long lasting lipstick.

I liked it

The media could not be loaded.  I got the black one. I was so glad to see that it was a good true black! Dries to a semi-matte of sorts, feels nice to put on, and smells lovely while it’s still liquid.The claims about it being waterproof and wearable for 24 hours are true if you’re not using your lips. Talking, and moving your lips in general is fine; stays perfect! Touching with you finger or giving a few kisses leaves very slight transfer (WAY less than other lipsticks I have) but your lips still look fine.If you eat ANYTHING for any amount of time you loose the lipstick on the edges of your mouth. Drinking things should be fine, but I have a habit of licking my lips while I drink… I tried to show this in the last picture I uploaded (first picture shown). In that picture my mouth is closed, so you can see where it’s gone. I did it again another day and lost a lot more after eating a meal but forgot to take a picture. 😅 I hope the video I uploaded helps paint a good picture.But I really like it! I think it might be ok to wear with a mask, though I have yet to really test that. When I wear it places I’ll def bring the tube with me for touch-ups. I might buy the blue one next…

The media could not be loaded.  I got the colors 20,23,19I think these are really good lipsticks and it’s also a good deal that they come with lip liners as well because you don’t usually find deals like that for this cheap. Not they obviously aren’t maybelline or any type of high end brand so they will get messed up when you eat but that’s not a problem for me. They will be worth your buy though

Gave me the perfect lip combination😝

I just received this yesterday. I love the pencil and the color is spot on beautiful. It was weirdly sticky so next time I will use lip gloss on top to see if that helps. I found myself continually licking my lips to take the stickiness away. It may be a fluke but I love the color and stays on forever. Price was great. Don’t forget the lipgloss if you buy.

Waterproof? Yes! Smudge proof? Yes! Long lasting? Yes!